And yet, in these times of dreary crisis, what is the point of emphasizing the horror of being?
Perhaps those that the path of analysis, or scription, or of a painful or ecstatic ordeal has led to tear the veil of the communitarian mystery, on which love of self and others is set up, only to catch a glimpse of the abyss of abjection with which they are underlaid–they perhaps might be able to read this book as something other than an intellectual exercise. For abjection, when all is said and done, is the other facet of religious, moral, and ideological codes on which rest the sleep of individuals and the breathing spells of societies. Such codes are abjection’s purification and repression. But the return of their repressed make up our “apocalypse” (Kristeva 208-209).
I was off campus when I received the armed person alert. For the hour it lasted, I remained immobile, fixated on my phone screen, continuously refreshing the university webpage for any updates or information I might have missed. My mind conjured hundreds of “worst-case” scenarios, nearly all of them involving my undergraduate students, many of whom, I knew, would be on campus, experiencing the threat in real time. It wasn’t until the emergency had passed— with no students or university personnel physically harmed— that I recognized the uncanny parallels between this incident and many of the themes I had been exploring with my students throughout the semester in my “Horror, Hell, and Monsters” seminar. Our class offered a space to reflect on this moment, to consider how our university handled horror on its campus—how we could think about horror and care for each other in its aftermath differently.
In class, my students and I frequently found ourselves pressed against the limits of language, fumbling over attempts to articulate experiences that, by their very nature, evade explanation through established social scripts. We discovered early on that the work of analyzing horror is messy—not only due to its association with the grotesque and erotic, but also because of its discursive unwieldiness: its tendency to trouble binary categories, unsettling neat distinctions between self and other, sacred and profane, life and death. Encountering the horrific pushed us beyond the threshold of rational discourse. It challenged us to pursue more creative modes of expression, questioning “common-sense” notions of how we stand in relationship to others and the world around us.
Julia Kristeva’s concept of abjection became a helpful term as our class mined the nuances of horror. Kristeva’s description of the “abject” (exemplified by, among other things, a human corpse, a violently criminal act, repulsive food products, or bodily waste) as that which one must “permanently thrust aside in order to live” gave us language to name and discuss the horrors hovering at the periphery of everyday human experience (3). The abject embodies physical and emotional excess, the limitations of naturalized moral frameworks, the disavowed truths that disturb the parameters of neatly packaged narratives. With this in mind, we approached our study of abjection as a project of unveiling. We asked: Which realities lay “thrust aside,” haunting our value systems, institutional rituals, and political mythologies? What anxieties lurk beneath purportedly all-encompassing epistemologies claiming to offer a totalizing account of how the world is or how it should be?
Addressing these questions required a great deal of care. Whether analyzing fictional novels and films, religious texts, or contemporary political media, our discussions of the abject often turned to a more intimate register as students shared personal fears and experiences, seeking to understand their own distinctive realities and what lay on the underside of their everyday lives. The scholarship we read—Adriana Caverero’s Horrorism, Jasbir Puar and Amit Rai’s “Monster, Terrorist, Fag,” Adam Kotsko’s The Prince of This World—offered lenses that helped us interrogate this underside, probing the silences at the heart of familiar narratives without promising a satisfying or comprehensive answer to the questions we raised. Through our readings and conversations, we learned to attend to one another as colleagues and resources but also as fragile and fallible individuals in pursuit of the unknown. In our explorations of this unanswerable uncertainty, we took care to create space for multiple interpretations of a reality that seemed to continuously elude capture within any singular frame.
…
No amount of reading or analysis could prepare us for the acute horror of the armed person alert. “Run, Hide, or Fight”: Sent via text on an otherwise unremarkable Tuesday morning, these four words transformed— or perhaps unveiled— the campus into a scene reminiscent of many we’d witnessed in the horror films we watched. Crowds broke out in a sprint; students and teachers barricaded doors, turned off lights, huddled under desks. The veneer of safety and protection—the “bubble” of the university campus—was laid bare as a soporific fiction. Realities thrust aside (our susceptibility to harm; the pervasiveness of gun violence; the failure of campus police to guarantee our protection) forcefully confronted us as we struggled to navigate a world momentarily stripped of its ordinary customs and significations.
Students would later tell me that, over the hour the alert remained in effect, group chats became hotbeds of misinformation, issuing false reports of the armed person’s supposed location or circulating AI-generated images portraying the threat as a Black man. With sparse, and frustratingly vague, snippets of information circulated through the school’s emergency messaging system, new narratives emerged to fill in the gaps, playing on anxieties and biases that, however harmful and distortive, provided a pretense of certainty amid the confused liminality of waiting. These fictions became a spectral presence in buildings across the university, difficult to ignore even after the alert was dismissed.
Campus resumed normal operations immediately following an all-clear from the police. But, I wondered, what could this “normalcy” entail? In our class the following day, I deliberated about my own role as an instructor in the aftermath of the alert. A tentative question posed at the beginning of class (“Is this something you want to talk about?”) led to an outpouring of student responses. Some students described the panic coursing through their bodies as they sprinted toward shelter or locked themselves in bathrooms, feelings that reemerged upon entering classrooms they had been warned to avoid mere hours before. Others expressed an ambivalence— “I feel like I should have been more scared,” one admitted—pondering aloud whether the rampant regularity of gun violence and school shootings made this event feel somehow less real, less urgent. Despite differing responses to the threat, a common theme resonated through the students’ discussion: a profound disappointment in the university’s response to the danger and perplexity of the moment, its rush to return to “the way things were,” the stubborn anonymity (and subsequent lack of accountability) behind the faceless institutional messaging system. In short, it was not fear of an imagined shooter or a desire for more forceful security measures that prompted students’ criticisms. It was the institution’s failure to care.
…
I remain pessimistic about whether any university, however robust its student programming or noble its mission statement, can offer genuine care in the ways my students seemed to desire. But I don’t think this means that their critiques were futile or naïve. Their expressions of disappointment gestured toward the incapacity of institutional scripts to adequately name and respond to moments of horrific encounter, especially those that, like the armed person alert, have come to be regarded as “regular” occurrences, everyday risks inherent to life on a university campus. In lamenting the school’s uncommunicativeness and critiquing its haphazardly reconstructed façade of security and normality immediately following the crisis, students challenged the institution’s insistent push toward resolution, refusing to make the horrific “make sense” within the frameworks handed to them.
Scholars writing from a broad range of contexts have addressed this institutional impetus toward “normality” as a kind of violence in its own right. Several have explored how this impetus is frequently justified through the language of care. For example, Lisa Stevenson’s work names how state interventions designed to promote greater longevity among Indigenous communities in the Canadian Arctic often enact harm against the populations they claim to help, offering a vision of care that substitutes the bare “maintenance of life itself” for a deeper attention to the needs, desires, epistemologies, and experiences of those subjected to it (3). This “standardized” care reduces human existence to a series of statistics, with survival representing bureaucratic success and death representing bureaucratic failure (33). Here, care takes the shape of order, measurability, certainty: lives neatly quantified with little nuance and no remainders. Enacted through and on behalf of institutional entities, care often becomes generalized and, to a certain degree, anonymized—imposed on, rather than developed with, the “cared-for.”
In a recent special issue of The Scholar and Feminist Online, Premilla Nadasen and Alex Pittman invoke the term “carceral care” to describe how the maintenance and reproduction of a violent status quo can become branded as benign practices of “supervision, guardianship, and protection.” Attending to US prisons and ICE detention facilities as central sites of “carceral care”— in addition to other spaces invested in the work of anti-Blackness, settler colonialism, and racial capitalism— Nadasen and Pittman critique the ways that discourses of care often serve to transform systemic horrors into something more palatable, lending a semblance of benevolence to structures of harm and domination. Here again, appeals to bureaucratic innocence and orderliness present a narrative steeped in the denial of lived experiences and the messy, violent realities they convey.
Our class discussion of the armed person alert unveiled some of the violence intrinsic to the university’s seemingly benign, “normal” operations as well. The capitalist and carceral practices required for maintaining and patrolling the perimeters of the campus “bubble”— not to mention many institutions’ active, if often invisibilized, investment in global projects of war and imperialism— became more apparent upon considering what a return to “normalcy” demanded of us as members of the university community. This realization gave me pause. Had we become so focused on analyzing the horrors and injustices “out there” that we had neglected to examine the ways those same injustices showed up on campus and in our classroom?
The armed person alert and students’ refusal to accept the institutional narratives around it prompted me to reassess horror as a topic of studious inquiry— not only as a site of discipline and disruption but as a series of structures and events demanding a critical interrogation of and commitment to care. Whereas encounters with horror show us what we “must permanently thrust aside in order to live,” a commitment to care asks us to consider what “living” entails, in all of its messiness and precarity. An attention to care and horror together, as ideas and actions that push us toward an acknowledgement of the disorderly, violent, and vulnerable realities we occupy, may allow us to better respond (albeit always imperfectly, incompletely) to the crises of the present.
…
The students in my class did not express a need for the university to mitigate the horror of the armed person alert or to somehow make it simpler to digest. Rather, many voiced a desire for the opposite response: an acknowledgement of uncertainty, an embrace of multiple narratives and possibilities, a sustained attention to the structural dimensions of the crisis and the ways it stretched our categories of comprehension. We had engaged examples of this approach in the philosophical and religious texts we encountered in class, especially those thematizing excess— the unnamed or unnamable realities spilling out from sanitized, secular frameworks of knowing. But this was easier to explore on paper than to put into practice. The institutional push to systematize and manage horror— to maintain and legitimize the orderly operations of the everyday— transformed care into a project of preservation and palliation. In our classroom, we tried to imagine a different kind of care that embraced excess and allowed for uncertainty.
The experience of the armed person alert became a touchpoint in several of our future class discussions. We discovered an urgency in confronting the abject, ushering in the apocalyptic “return of [the] repressed” that Kristeva proclaimed in her work— not as a project of tearing down, per se, but of seeing beyond, and perhaps creating, practices of care unbeholden to institutional norms.